Fred speaks in Immigration.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C8AL7zMMTB4
From the audio...
"...and that would give the proponents of the bill a chance to explain why putting illegals in a more favorable position than those that play by the rules, is not really amnesty."
I agree. Tell me why it's not amnesty; explain to me why playing by the rules is wrong, and why being rewarded for not playing by the rules is not being placed in a favorable position. (Okay, a few too many negatives, I agree.)
If everything is just a misunderstanding, why are fines and applications involved? Do we expect those who ignored our rule of law will now embrace it? Other than hope, what is the basis for that belief?
Rule of law. Playing by the rules. That's the rub, I guess, for most of us that are like-minded.
I've never been an immigrant. My mom, and her mom were. My nephew is. Go back even a few more generations, and most everyone in the family was. English, Italian, Dutch, Brazilian.
Immigration was a lengthy process for all, but it was achievable. It was honorable. It was what the rules required. And it led to a naturalization certificate, the official stamp of citizenship. For my mom, she cherished that honor to her last day.
She was a war bride of an 8th Air Force Navigator. She understood, firsthand, what a force for good the United Stated could be. She married and moved. She applied. She learned the Pledge of Allegiance, she studied American history, and she wept in waves for JFK. It was what her adopted country required and deserved. She was an American.
My nephew was abandoned to an orphanage not far from São Paulo. It's been fourteen years since his adoption. He knows, firsthand, how others live, and how his life has changed. He knows that opportunity arrived, and that some friends didn't have the chance. He graduates high school in a few weeks, and longs to become a commercial artist. He is American.
So what's the big deal about illegal immigration? Obviously, immigrants do quite well.
To my mind, it's fairness. Some play by the rules; some cheat. Some are rewarded; some are punished. Some wear their citizenship discreetly, others, their non-citizenship as boldly.
If you play by the rules, you are relegated to a lengthy process that may or may not guarantee citizenship. If you cheat, just wait a bit and you'll get citizenship anyway. No problem, no pesky waiting period. Cut in line. Others are dopes. It's all about me. Game the system and win. Respect the system and lose.
The immigration bill currently under debate says all my mom did was for naught. All my sister went through was silly. Down is up, wrong is right, shield, sword, law, order, right, privilege, chaos. It's all irrelevant.
Play by the rules? Why bother?
Because in a land founded on the rule of law, it should matter.